Staten Island, NY  •  Family owned. Sandwich obsessed.  •  Open today for pickup
A Staten Island original

Good bread.
Big sandwiches.
No shortcuts.

Italian sandwiches made fresh, stacked generously, and remembered long after lunch. Come hungry. Leave happy.

Order OnlineView the Printed MenuMeet the favorites
Fresh sandwiches and salads, made daily
Anthony’s Paninoteca owner holding a generously stacked Italian sandwich
Made fresh dailyFamily owned
Made with
love on Staten Island
Italian heroes✳Fresh every day✳Big neighborhood energy✳Anthony’s Paninoteca
The ones people talk about

Meet the favorites

Big, craveable sandwiches and a different special every day. Find your next favorite on the full menu.

The Godfather stacked with Italian cold cuts, cheese, and roasted peppers on crusty bread01 / HOUSE FAVORITE

The Godfather

Prosciutto, soppressata, capicola, mortadella, provolone, mozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic, oil & vinegar.

See the full menu
Panino Golfetta on Anthony’s schiacciata bread, with salami, fresh mozzarella, roasted tomato, and greens02 / MUST TRY

Panino Golfetta

Golfetta salami, parmesan cream, arugula, fresh mozzarella, truffle oil, and lemon.

See the full menu
The Maria with mortadella, fried eggplant, mozzarella, and roasted peppers on Anthony’s panino bread03 / FAN FAVORITE

The Maria

Mortadella, fresh mozzarella, sharp provolone, fried eggplant, roasted peppers, pesto, oil & vinegar.

See the full menu
Fresh roast beef sandwich on crusty Italian bread04 / LOCAL LEGEND

Do It for Johnny

Roast beef, mozzarella, caramelized onions, and hot gravy.

See the full menu
Explore the Full Menu
Anthony’s Paninoteca team showcasing a house-made pastrami sandwich
Family owned. Staten Island proud.

Made fresh.
Made with heart.

Anthony’s Paninoteca is a family-owned neighborhood sandwich shop built around doing the simple things right: quality ingredients, fresh preparation, generous sandwiches, and the kind of welcome that makes you feel like a regular.

Whether you’re stopping in for your usual or trying something new from the daily specials, there’s always a good reason to come hungry.

Come say hello
See you at the shop.
A new reason to stop by

Today’s special
is calling.

There’s a different special every day at Anthony’s. Check the online menu for what’s fresh, then make lunch the best part of your day.

See today’s menu
A burger and fries from Anthony’s menu
Bring the good stuff

Feed the whole
crew.

Office lunch, family party, game day, or a table full of hungry friends: Anthony’s catering brings the sandwiches everyone reaches for first.

Tell us what you’re planning and the team can help you put together a spread.

Call about catering
Anthony’s round catering platter with assorted sandwich halves ready to shareA second Anthony’s sandwich platter prepared for a group
Anthony’s cateringSandwiches for the whole crew
Word gets around

Don’t just take ours

People come for a sandwich and leave planning their next visit. Here are a few things customers have shared.

“Anthony is a master of his craft. I got the Godfather and the Golfetta and I was hooked.”
Sandwich regular
“The sandwiches here are incredible!! Huge and amazing combos! They have a different special every day.”
Staten Island customer
“Best sandwich catering! Ordered a variety of sandwiches and each one was absolutely delicious.”
Catering customer
Your new lunch spot

Find us on
Amboy Road.

3994 Amboy Rd
Staten Island, NY 10308
Come in, call ahead, or order online for pickup.
(914) 458-5645
Order OnlineGet Directions

Shop hours

Monday – Saturday11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Sunday11:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Anthony’s Paninoteca3994 Amboy Rd · Staten IslandOpen in Maps